Have you ever wondered why your nonprofit cannot connect personally with individual donors? You might feel confident about your corporate donors, but your campaign messaging seems flat regarding individuals. You might be facing a storytelling gap.
Table of Contents
What is a Storytelling Gap?
No, this isn't another buzzphrase—it's a natural barrier that snuffs your impact. The Storytelling Gap happens when a great story is not told well enough for individual donors to care about it. I often see this issue in nonprofit communications. It's one of the reasons I'm leading BairStories to transform how 100 environmental organizations communicate their impact.
Causes a Storytelling Gap
- Time Constraints: The demands of program work often overshadow any storytelling efforts.
- Lack of Expertise: Not knowing how to create stories that resonate emotionally with the audience.
- Data Dumping: The tendency to focus on numbers doesn't convey the impact like an emotive story.
78% of donors seek information on a cause's essential long-term benefits, and 62% want to know if you use practical approaches. 1 If your existing storytelling doesn't connect the dots between what you are and why it works, you leave them with many disconnected numbers.
Common Signs of Not Resonating with Individual Donors?
If you've gone to a doctor for a diagnosis, you know how helpful it can be to know what concerns you. Similarly, identifying the symptoms of a storytelling gap is just as crucial. Here are some quick self-diagnosis questions.
Quick Check: Are You Facing a Storytelling Gap?
- Do donors give once and disappear?
- Are we clearly articulating why this issue exists and why our approach matters?
- Are we leading with data instead of emotional stories?
- Are our messages too general or impersonal?
- Are we sharing how our work aligns with proven best practices?
- Do donors see how our mission connects to their values?
- Are we not building rapport with each donor through personalization?
Based on insights from the "Why American Gives" donor report, here are some signs:
- Low Engagement in Communication Channels: Your nonprofit communications (emails, newsletters, and social media posts) are not generating the interest or interaction you want.
- Disconnection: A misunderstanding or disconnect between your nonprofit and its community.
- High Donor Turnover: When nonprofit donors give once and do not return, it can suggest that your nonprofit is not building a strong emotional connection or effectively demonstrating ongoing impact.
- Overreliance on Data: Using primarily numerical data and metrics in your communications without connecting them to personal stories can inform but not inspire.
- Impersonal Mass Communications: Sending generalized messages instead of personalized communications can make donors feel like just another number rather than valued supporters.
- Difficulty Matching Values: If donors struggle to see how your nonprofit's values align with theirs, this can indicate a gap in effectively communicating them.
- Limited Donor Involvement: If nonprofit donors do not participate in volunteer opportunities or sign up for updates, your nonprofit may not create a sense of community and involvement.
How to Close A Storytelling Gap & Appeal to Individual Donors?
Donors often begin by looking into the issue, not your organization. 1 That means your story has to show up in the context of the broader struggle you are addressing. Engaging stories that create deeper connections and are discoverable will lead to greater engagement with individual donors.
01. Lead with Emotion, Back it with Proof:
Start with emotionally resonant stories that show lived impact—then support them with meaningful outcomes and long-term relevance.
02. Speak to Shared Values, Not Just Stats:
Frame your work in terms of what matters to your donors—highlighting the why behind your mission and impact (transformation) of your work.
03. Make It Personal and Timely:
Ditch the one-size-fits-all blasts. Use personal updates, segmented messages, and flexible giving options to make donors feel seen and connected.
Real Stories That Changed Donor Behavior
Here's closing the storytelling gap in action. These short story films helped our clients move their audiences from informed to emotionally invested.
Two Storytelling Paths - You Choose
Do It Yourself
Lean into storytelling as a strategy and tool for donor connection. Through inspiring stories of transformation, help individual donors understand the long-term benefits of your work.
Additionally, mention how your organization's approach aligns with proven methods or benchmarks against others in the field. 1 Donors are hungry for that kind of context.
If storytelling seems overwhelming or you're looking for a place to start, check out our guide to crafting emotive stories. This guide contains the methods we use for our storytelling, which have helped a government state department avoid disbandment and secure a licensing deal with local PBS and WaterBear Network for our film Belonging.
Hire Help
Sometimes, you don't have the capacity to tell stories. Many of the clients we work with are in that same boat. At BairStories, we work alongside environmental organizations as strategic partners to identify the stories they're telling and convey their impact through stories that make the why tangible and human.
While donors say they want facts, impact, and comparisons, they often remember and act on the stories that bring those facts to life. That's where our work lives—at the intersection of trust, emotion, and human connection.
Discover the Stories Individual Donors Secretly Crave from You
You're sitting on a treasure of untold stories that could change how people see and respond to your invitation to fulfill your mission. By recognizing the signs of storytelling gaps and taking steps to address them, you can enhance your nonprofit's ability to connect with individual donors on a personal level.
Take this 5-minute quiz to find the stories you're not telling.
Related Articles
References
OpenAI's ChatGPT and Grammarly were used for revisions and feedback. Check out our AI Ethical Use Statement.