You're doing all the nonprofit content marketing advice. You're posting three times a week on social media, creating monthly newsletters, updating your website, and making Canva graphics between grant deadlines and board reports. You even tried video a couple of times.

But your open rates keep dropping. Social engagement feels like shouting into the void. And despite all this content marketing for nonprofits, you're not seeing the donations, volunteer sign-ups, or even email replies you need. Perhaps you've found yourself wondering, "Am I just not cut out for this marketing stuff?" Or looking at other environmental organizations and thinking, "They seem to have it figured out, what are we missing?"

You've Probably Noticed Something Strange

The more content you create, the more disconnected you feel from your mission. The busier you get with posts and newsletters, the less impact you're seeing.

When your environmental nonprofit is strapped for resources, this feeling becomes even more pronounced. You're already juggling program management, grant deadlines, and board reports—adding more content creation means more running in place, more exhaustion, and uncertainty about what moves the needle on climate engagement.

You might be thinking the solution is better tools, more time, or a bigger budget. But here's what I've observed working with environmental organizations: Even with unlimited time and budget, this disconnection would still occur.

Most environmental nonprofits fall into the trap of trying to spark change through heady informational pieces that don't move the heart. Or when they do move the heart, it's usually through fear. However, fear-based nonprofit content marketing can lead to compassion fatigue, rather than sustained engagement.

So let me ask you: when you hit "publish" on your latest post or newsletter, do you feel confident it's moving your mission forward? If not, there's a reason why your efforts aren't yielding the desired impact.

You're Not Imagining It: Something Is Missing from Your Nonprofit Content Marketing

Think about the last time you sent a newsletter or posted on social media. Did you feel that little knot in your stomach? That quiet voice asking, "Is this even helping anyone?"

Your supporters care deeply about environmental justice and the conservation of land and water. They subscribed because they want to feel connected to meaningful change. However, when your communications become a series of disconnected program updates, even the most passionate environmental advocates tend to tune out.

The result is consistently low open rates, weak click-through rates, and an increase in unsubscribes over time.

You need your supporters to care. But here's what might surprise you: Your audience doesn't want more information. They want specific information that helps them understand the impact. According to Root Causes' Donor Report, donors prioritize:

• Long-term benefits of solving a social issue (78%)
• Nonprofit impact data (75%)
• Who is affected and where (68%)
• What works (best practices, proven approaches)

Have you noticed that your most engaged supporters aren't necessarily the ones who consume the most content? They're the ones who understand why your work matters in a way that feels personal to them.

This Approach Is Counterintuitive for Nonprofit Content Marketing

Fewer stories, told strategically, will outperform more content every time. I know it seems backward when you're already worried about staying visible. However, there's a reason fewer stories, if they're the right ones, create more connection. Don't you want your organization's content to mean something? To reflect the heart of your climate mission, build trust with supporters, and make people feel connected enough to support (volunteer, donate, spread the word)?

Your Strategic Plan Holds Clues You Haven't Unlocked

From experience talking to our clients and prospects, I've noticed something puzzling: Most nonprofits spend weeks developing strategic plans, then create content that barely connects to those plans. You might be wondering: "Why does my content feel so disconnected from our organizational goals?"

Without this connection, your team starts to feel like their effort isn't worth it. Your communications become noise. Imagine receiving a comment or newsletter reply saying, "This moved me," or donors saying, "I understand why your work matters." Your work deserves those remarks. But, you cannot achieve that without the right stories that nurture and build deep, lasting relationships with your audience. Building the right stories starts with clarity, but it's not the kind of clarity you think.

Unlike other sectors that lead with marketing, nonprofits lead with the mission and work. This creates a unique challenge: you're so focused on program delivery that marketing feels secondary. Yet, your programs are full of untold stories that could transform your supporter relationships if you knew how to surface them.

There's a Reason Your Nonprofit Content Marketing Feels Like Starting From Scratch Each Month

You've probably experienced this: staring at your content calendar thinking, "What are we saying this month?" You have programs running, statistics to report, a grant deadline approaching, and you're still unsure what story to tell next. That feeling of starting over isn't a content problem. It's a signal that something fundamental is missing.

At BairStories, we view stories and content as two distinct yet interconnected entities. Stories refer to the message, preferably one that evokes a significant emotional experience. Content is the tangible aspect of all forms of marketing, including email, video, podcasts, social media, SEO, PR, PPC, inbound marketing, and digital marketing.

Imagine you've got a content strategy—a calendar with some themes. But each month feels like starting over. There's no through-line. You're unsure what the key message is or how it relates to where your organization is headed. You're using tools, but there's no system guiding them.

When you shift your focus from content to storytelling, you think holistically. You create content pieces that interact with each other, telling a larger story. You gain confidence because you know what to say next. You understand what your audience needs to hear next.

Have you ever wondered why some nonprofits seem to know exactly what to communicate, while others struggle to convey their message effectively? There's a reason for this difference.

What You're Missing Has a Name

Even if you have the best content strategy in the world, without the underlying framework, you're building on shaky ground. Most nonprofits have a content strategy, which typically includes posts, newsletters, and possibly videos. But what's missing is the internal structure that tells you which stories to tell and why. Without that, content becomes disconnected updates that disappear into the void.

This missing piece is what I call story infrastructure. Here's an example of story infrastructure in action:

We worked with Environmental Initiative on their year-end fundraiser video. Through pre-interviews with employees and stakeholders, I discovered a transformation story they weren't telling publicly—their organizational shift toward diversity and inclusion that changed their core values. Although the timing didn't allow us to use this story for the fundraiser, it now provides a powerful narrative tool for partner meetings and relationship-building. That's the difference between content and story infrastructure—one creates material, the other creates meaning.

Think of your strategic plan as your organization's blueprint—it lays out where you're headed. Story infrastructure is what makes that plan communicable. The foundation is clarity: clarity on who you are, where you're going, and what story draws people to follow you. When that's in place, every email, video, caption, or photo becomes easier to manage. Not because you're doing less, but because every piece has meaning.

The Change You Seek Won't Appear Like Magic

I know you're passionate about creating a just and sustainable world. Working in an environmental nonprofit can feel like you're working with one arm tied behind your back. The climate crisis demands urgency, but your communication resources are limited.

Even if you doubled your content output tomorrow, without a story infrastructure, you'd create more noise. You're already putting in tremendous effort. I want you to channel that effort strategically so you can breathe. Inhale.

That's possible by reorienting your content marketing for nonprofits around a story-first approach—a new approach driven by your storytelling infrastructure, rooted in your organization's vision and values. This is a concept I'm developing and applying to my own company, BairStories, based on what I've observed to be most effective with environmental organizations. Instead of communications centered on programmatic updates that don't land, picture stories that you and your team feel proud of. The type of stories that reflect who you are, not just what you do, and draw people into your environmental mission. Exhale.

Dive Deeper Into Storytelling Infrastructure and Take the First Step Towards That Change

What story is your environmental nonprofit telling right now? And more importantly, is it the story that will move your supporters to take climate action? The answer to that question depends on whether you have the right infrastructure in place or whether you're still building on shaky ground.

Ready to stop feeling like your content marketing efforts are pointless? Learn how to build a storytelling infrastructure system that connects your strategic plan to content that moves people to take climate action.

Related Articles

• Before You Invest in Video, Build Your Storytelling Infrastructure
• Holistic Storytelling: The Ultimate Guide 
• Your Climate Action Plan Is Missing this One Thing
• What’s Storytelling Got to Do With Nonprofit Strategic Planning?
• Focus On A Content Strategy Before Video Storytelling

Artificial intelligence (AI) was used in the creation of this article. Check out our AI Ethical Use Statement.